Ocean

China accuses Chile and Belgium of ‘backroom deal’ as tensions rise over high seas treaty HQ

A relatively obscure race to host the secretariat of a global ocean treaty has turned into a political row, and a headache for those hoping the treaty could advance conservation
<p>Fishing boats head out from Rongcheng, Shandong province (Image: Li Xinjun / Xinhua / Alamy)</p>

Fishing boats head out from Rongcheng, Shandong province (Image: Li Xinjun / Xinhua / Alamy)

China has reacted with barely disguised fury after its bid to host its first UN body appeared to have been derailed by a combination of Chile and Belgium.

Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Mao Ning denounced the rival nations’ move as “an unauthorised backroom deal” that contravenes agreed procedures and precedence.

Ocean scientists and conservationists are watching nervously, as the row threatens to derail the first meeting of a new international treaty governing the protection of life in the high seas, those parts of the ocean beyond nations’ control.

China, which has a large distant-water fishing fleet, is increasingly involved in global negotiations on ocean conservation, such as around Antarctica, and deep-sea mining. Chile has also positioned itself as a leader on high seas issues.

Some are worried that the high-profile row before the treaty is even properly up and running could put the brakes on ocean protection, such as the push to protect 30% of the ocean by 2030 which requires a huge scale-up of marine protected areas on the high seas.

The race to host

Belgium, Chile and China all made separate bids to host the headquarters of the high seas treaty, also known as the BBNJ (Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction) agreement.

China’s bid has been seen as an indicator of the country’s willingness to play a major role in global environmental processes, after the United States has largely withdrawn from this space during President Donald Trump’s second term in office.

The location of the secretariat is set to be decided in New York in January at the first conference of the parties (COP) to the treaty. If countries fail to reach consensus, a vote among member states is likely to take place. China’s attempt to bring the body to Xiamen was in pole position, according to several sources from inside and outside China, but this confidence was shaken after Chile and Belgium combined their bids earlier this month. They offered to host the secretariat in Valparaíso and another part of the treaty in Brussels. That is, the Clearing-House Mechanism, a digital platform that stores data and facilitates information exchange.

The Chinese candidacy has been promoted by multiple articles across state media outlets this year. Insiders say behind the scenes lobbying from different candidates has also been going on bilaterally and during diplomatic events. As late as last month one well-connected ocean source who is not affiliated with China told Dialogue Earth that they expect Xiamen’s bid to win in New York.

Mao Ning said “Belgium and Chile traded under the table” in “an act of disrespect to the authority of COP”. Belgium’s foreign ministry declined to comment beyond its initial announcement of the joint bid which promised to work “in collaboration with all parties and observers”. Dialogue Earth has approached Chile’s foreign ministry for comment.

The closest example of an environmental treaty having a joint secretariat is the Rotterdam Convention on hazardous chemicals, which is provided by both the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) in Geneva and the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) in Rome. 

But that convention specifies the secretariat should be performed by the two institutions, said Zhang Xinjun, a law professor at Tsinghua University, in a webinar this week. Whereas the BBNJ agreement only mentions “host state” singular. Belgium and Chile should clarify how the joint candidacy fits in the provision, he added.

If Belgium and Chile are allowed to update their proposals, Zhang added, China should have a reasonable opportunity to update theirs. Other experts at the webinar, hosted by Huayang Center for Maritime Cooperation and Ocean Governance, a Hainan-based think-tank, also raised the concern about the costs of having a joint secretariat located across continents.

Being home to the BBNJ would be prestigious for any country. If it goes to China, it will be the first such body with a headquarters anywhere in Asia, and if it goes to Chile, the first in Latin America. 

Hoping for a deal

Many of those involved in the BBNJ process are reluctant to go on record and comment given how politically charged the issue has become. A representative of a country not bidding for the HQ said they were very surprised by the joint bid appearing, but hoped a deal could be reached in New York that would not leave China feeling excluded. One China expert said the foreign ministry statement was very significant, and it would be hard to resolve the situation in New York now given the level of politics involved.

Liz Karan, director of ocean governance at Pew Charitable Trusts, told Dialogue Earth she is surprised at the widespread attention on the issue, given that hosting the secretariat is often seen as an administrative role. “It is exciting to see that there is a lot of interest… Hopefully, the interest is in making it work, not in preventing progress,” she says. 

She says it would concern her, though, if countries failed to decide on the location of the headquarters in January, as that would delay implementation of the treaty. However, she remains confident that member states will find a way to reach consensus in the coming two months. Stalling progress would be counterproductive to what, she believes, the candidates set out to do. 

“There are bigger issues that are going to be more controversial moving forward,” she adds. “I don’t see the benefits of starting off, on these administrative issues, in a divisive vote.” 

Cookies Settings

Dialogue Earth uses cookies to provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser. It allows us to recognise you when you return to Dialogue Earth and helps us to understand which sections of the website you find useful.

Required Cookies

Required Cookies should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

Dialogue Earth - Dialogue Earth is an independent organisation dedicated to promoting a common understanding of the world's urgent environmental challenges. Read our privacy policy.

Cloudflare - Cloudflare is a service used for the purposes of increasing the security and performance of web sites and services. Read Cloudflare's privacy policy and terms of service.

Functional Cookies

Dialogue Earth uses several functional cookies to collect anonymous information such as the number of site visitors and the most popular pages. Keeping these cookies enabled helps us to improve our website.

Google Analytics - The Google Analytics cookies are used to gather anonymous information about how you use our websites. We use this information to improve our sites and report on the reach of our content. Read Google's privacy policy and terms of service.

Advertising Cookies

This website uses the following additional cookies:

Google Inc. - Google operates Google Ads, Display & Video 360, and Google Ad Manager. These services allow advertisers to plan, execute and analyze marketing programs with greater ease and efficiency, while enabling publishers to maximize their returns from online advertising. Note that you may see cookies placed by Google for advertising, including the opt out cookie, under the Google.com or DoubleClick.net domains.

Twitter - Twitter is a real-time information network that connects you to the latest stories, ideas, opinions and news about what you find interesting. Simply find the accounts you find compelling and follow the conversations.

Facebook Inc. - Facebook is an online social networking service. China Dialogue aims to help guide our readers to content that they are interested in, so they can continue to read more of what they enjoy. If you are a social media user, then we are able to do this through a pixel provided by Facebook, which allows Facebook to place cookies on your web browser. For example, when a Facebook user returns to Facebook from our site, Facebook can identify them as part of a group of China Dialogue readers, and deliver them marketing messages from us, i.e. more of our content on biodiversity. Data that can be obtained through this is limited to the URL of the pages that have been visited and the limited information a browser might pass on, such as its IP address. In addition to the cookie controls that we mentioned above, if you are a Facebook user you can opt out by following this link.

Linkedin - LinkedIn is a business- and employment-oriented social networking service that operates via websites and mobile apps.