Climate

Opinion: The Super El Niño reminds us that migration rights must be a priority

Climatologist and geographer Nasser Karami says limiting movement leaves communities stranded even before a disaster strikes, as examples from South and West Asia show
<p>A shepherdess travels with donkeys carrying supplies and young goats in Balochistan, Pakistan (Image: Amazing Aerial / Alamy)</p>

A shepherdess travels with donkeys carrying supplies and young goats in Balochistan, Pakistan (Image: Amazing Aerial / Alamy)

“Super El Niño” conditions around the world are making climate displacement an escalating concern. “A supersized El Niño is colliding with a planet already superheated by manmade climate change,” UN Secretary-General António Guterres said at COP31. “Climate records keep falling. The human costs keep rising.”

The unrelenting heat is now expected to spill “well into 2027”, according to the World Meteorological Organization. In mid-November, the US government’s National Weather Service estimated a greater than 79% chance of a strong-to-very-strong El Niño persisting through January-March 2027.

El Niño affects places and seasons differently. Yet while droughts and floods can’t be attributed to it without analysis, the phenomenon worsens weather extremes. Crucially, it also serves as a test of political and legal systems: when people must move due to these conditions, where can they go?

That test is especially urgent in the South Asian drylands that meet West Asia. Historically, people in this region dealt with variability in rainfall, pasture and water availability by storing water or changing crops. But they also coped by moving. Pastoral families followed grass and water between ecological zones, while others moved in search of livelihoods when a harvest failed.

Such journeys were temporary, ordinary means of adapting to environmental factors. In some cases, they span historical regions that are now divided by political borders. Climatic pressures are increasing the importance of these traditional coping strategies, but borders have made them increasingly impossible to carry out.

A modern phenomenon

The current map of the Iran-Afghanistan-Pakistan region places political divisions over a sprawling ecological landscape that doesn’t stop neatly at borders.

One example of this is the Helmand River. It rises in Afghanistan and flows south-west across much of the country, feeding the transboundary Sistan basin and Hamoun wetlands along the Iranian border, sustaining farming, fishing and other livelihoods. But upstream withdrawals and decisions about water management in Afghanistan have affected the wetlands downstream, as has drought, notes a 2024 UN Development Programme project report. It states that wetland degradation has led to impacts such as greater dust-storm exposure and crippling pressure on local livelihoods in the Iranian Sistan.

The ecological and social costs of these issues are transboundary; the dust storms and drying of water bodies also impact Afghan settlements. Accordingly, Iran and Afghanistan should seek to improve water management collaboration. But where restoration is insufficient in sustaining communities, the countries should work together to support alternative livelihoods and voluntary mobility.

Diplomatic relations are going in the opposite direction, however. In 2025, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) logged about 2.9 million Afghan returns from neighbouring countries. This was driven by tightening documentation regimes, misinformation, and deteriorating socio-economic and protection conditions for Afghans in Iran and Pakistan, the UNHCR noted. They returned to a country facing strained services, insecure livelihoods and recurring climate hazards.

Further south from the Helmand, Balochistan’s problem is one of shrinking spaces for nomadic movement. The historical region’s inhabited and pastoral landscapes extend across Iran, Pakistan and Afghanistan. Several of the key borders dividing them were established in the 19th century. A 2025 study of Kuchi (meaning nomadic or semi-nomadic) pastoralists in northern Balochistan traces their seasonal and trading routes, as well as the places where families camped and kept livestock.

“These modern nomads used to freely cross the international boundary of Pakistan, Afghanistan and the Central Asian states, travelling as far as Bengal and Burma to trade,” the study notes. But international politics, conflict and border restrictions mean their scope for movement has been “drastically reduced”. Now, they primarily move through Balochistan into the Indus valley in Pakistan’s Sindh province trading Afghan goods.

They face other pressures as well. A 2023 report from the humanitarian analysis non-profit Acaps notes that about 70% of all disputes in Afghanistan are land-based. They occur over issues such as access to grazing land and the conversion or allocation of land for other uses, which greatly affects Kuchi pastoralists. Severe poverty has also been noted among Kuchi households. These issues have been linked to population strains and climate change, the report notes.

For many Kuchi communities, restrictions on legal and practical routes have hurt their ability to trade and deal with seasonal ecological variation. But more than that, curtailing of movement, whether due to border policies or land conflict, leaves them with fewer viable places to go when exceptional droughts or other shocks occur.

Right to migrate

The examples of border disputes and shrinking areas of allowed movement reveal a glaring gap in international law. Article 13 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights recognises the right to leave any country and return to one’s own, while Article 14 recognises the right to seek asylum from persecution. But no general right exists to enter and settle in another nation.  

Landmark decisions like the UN Human Rights Committee’s ruling in Ioane Teitiota v New Zealand show the law generally only protects individuals facing personal and imminent threats to their life. It acknowledged that severe climate impacts may, in some circumstances, bar a state from returning a person to a place where their right to life would face a real risk. But this is not a practical solution for families whose livelihoods are disappearing gradually, before they are displaced.

Governments of climate-vulnerable countries like those in South and West Asia should begin negotiating pathways for people whose adaptation options are narrowing.

Receiving states understandably have concerns about housing, services, security and the pace of demographic change. But having to rely entirely on individual governments’ discretion for entry means people may be left with no assured next step when disaster strikes.

Making room

Realistically, most climate-related movement is currently likely to remain within countries, as international moves involve largely prohibitive costs and legal barriers. South Asia is projected to have as many as 40 million internal climate migrants by 2050, according to a 2021 World Bank report. But internal relocation will not be the answer in every case.

Pakistan’s 2022 floods led to about 8.2 million internal displacements, according to the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre. During its 2025 floods, more than 3.5 million people were temporarily displaced at the height of the disaster, according to UN figures cited by the International Organization for Migration. Many of the same areas were struck in both floods, demonstrating the limits of infrastructural capacity, which was overwhelmed. Such repeated sudden disasters threaten to exhaust a country’s finances and cause permanent vulnerability. Compounding crises could also cause displacement to spill over into other countries involuntarily.

group of people boarding colourful bus
People board a bus in the Pakistan city of Thatta to evacuate as Cyclone Biparjoy approaches (Image: Ahmad Kamal / IMAGO / Alamy)

Across the Balochistan historical region, too, drought and water insecurity create pressures on livelihoods in Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan, albeit in different ways. But modern borders leave pastoral and other communities stranded when facing localised climate shocks.

Where established pastoral routes cross borders, governments could negotiate regulated seasonal access or cross-border work arrangements. For large scale disasters, if return is unsafe or there are no longer any ways to adapt to the changing climate locally, they should reopen discussions for temporary residence, regional agreements for movement, or longer-term relocation. These measures would require clear rules, local participation and fair cost sharing.

In the Iran-Pakistan-Afghanistan region, such cooperation is likely to be met with significant political resistance given the border issues and strained relations Afghanistan currently has with its neighbours. But as seen in the Helmand and Hamoun basins, the impacts of ecological issues transcend borders. Receiving states may be hesitant to open people corridors. But the alternative, when countries’ infrastructure can no longer cope with cycles of climate disasters, may be chaotic border surges. Controlled migration may thus be a tool for stability, and even narrow agreements today can go a long way.

Climate justice is commonly framed around adaptation finance and loss and damage. But financing defences like pasture restoration or flood prevention may prove insufficient if disasters keep repeating and exhausting local capacities, especially if such financing is not generous. As we have seen around the world, and particularly in Asia, the Super El Niño is severely straining such capacities. Mobility should therefore have a more prominent place in such discussions, alongside efforts to make life possible where people already call home.

Cookies Settings

Dialogue Earth uses cookies to provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser. It allows us to recognise you when you return to Dialogue Earth and helps us to understand which sections of the website you find useful.

Required Cookies

Required Cookies should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

Dialogue Earth - Dialogue Earth is an independent organisation dedicated to promoting a common understanding of the world's urgent environmental challenges. Read our privacy policy.

Cloudflare - Cloudflare is a service used for the purposes of increasing the security and performance of web sites and services. Read Cloudflare's privacy policy and terms of service.

Functional Cookies

Dialogue Earth uses several functional cookies to collect anonymous information such as the number of site visitors and the most popular pages. Keeping these cookies enabled helps us to improve our website.

Google Analytics - The Google Analytics cookies are used to gather anonymous information about how you use our websites. We use this information to improve our sites and report on the reach of our content. Read Google's privacy policy and terms of service.

Advertising Cookies

This website uses the following additional cookies:

Google Inc. - Google operates Google Ads, Display & Video 360, and Google Ad Manager. These services allow advertisers to plan, execute and analyze marketing programs with greater ease and efficiency, while enabling publishers to maximize their returns from online advertising. Note that you may see cookies placed by Google for advertising, including the opt out cookie, under the Google.com or DoubleClick.net domains.

Twitter - Twitter is a real-time information network that connects you to the latest stories, ideas, opinions and news about what you find interesting. Simply find the accounts you find compelling and follow the conversations.

Facebook Inc. - Facebook is an online social networking service. China Dialogue aims to help guide our readers to content that they are interested in, so they can continue to read more of what they enjoy. If you are a social media user, then we are able to do this through a pixel provided by Facebook, which allows Facebook to place cookies on your web browser. For example, when a Facebook user returns to Facebook from our site, Facebook can identify them as part of a group of China Dialogue readers, and deliver them marketing messages from us, i.e. more of our content on biodiversity. Data that can be obtained through this is limited to the URL of the pages that have been visited and the limited information a browser might pass on, such as its IP address. In addition to the cookie controls that we mentioned above, if you are a Facebook user you can opt out by following this link.

Linkedin - LinkedIn is a business- and employment-oriented social networking service that operates via websites and mobile apps.